Your Own Backup System or a Cloud Backup Service: Control, Cost and Dependence
For most small and medium-sized businesses with more than a couple of terabytes of files, your own backup system is the better deal: the data stays inside the company, you pay for the equipment once instead of every month, no provider can raise the price on you, and a full restore takes hours instead of days. The cloud is better when you have little data, no office for the equipment or nobody to look after it. For many companies the strongest answer is a mix: your own system in the office plus an encrypted copy at a second location you also control. Here is an honest comparison of control, cost and dependence – the questions we go through with every client who asks us about cybersecurity and data protection.
Three Monday mornings
- The file server won't start. With your own backup system, everything comes back over the office network in hours. With a cloud-only backup, you start downloading several terabytes through your internet line – and the whole team waits.
- An email from your provider: "Updated pricing". With your own system, nothing changes. With a cloud service, you pay the new price or move terabytes of data somewhere else.
- A client asks where their data is kept. With your own system the answer is simple: "in our office, on equipment we own, encrypted with keys only we hold". With a cloud service, it depends on the provider's contracts, data centres and home country.
The case for your own system
Your data never leaves the company. Contracts, accounts, client files and email archives stay on equipment you own, encrypted with keys that only you hold. Conversations with clients, auditors and regulators become much simpler – see what NIS2 and GDPR require for backups and encryption.
No monthly fee per user or per terabyte. You buy the equipment once. The bill doesn't grow every time you hire someone or your files grow by another terabyte.
Nobody can change the price on you. Cloud prices move – and lately mostly upwards:
- Backblaze raised the price of its B2 cloud storage in October 2023, and again from 1 May 2026.
- Wasabi raised its pay-as-you-go storage price from 1 July 2026 – for new and existing customers in all regions – citing higher costs for storage hardware, energy and data centres.
- Microsoft raised the per-user prices of Microsoft 365 Business Basic and Business Standard from 1 July 2026.
Each may be justified, but each lands on your budget without your say – and moving terabytes elsewhere to avoid it takes time and effort.
It can work with no internet at all. If you choose, the system can be completely disconnected from the internet. What isn't connected can't be reached from outside – a strong argument for accountants, medical practices, law firms and anyone who keeps sensitive records.
Restores at office speed. Simple arithmetic: downloading 5 TB over a 100 Mbit/s internet line takes about four and a half days – non-stop, at full speed. Over a 1 Gbit/s office network, the same 5 TB takes about 11 hours. When the whole team is waiting for its files, that gap is measured in lost working days.
You know which law applies. Many of the largest cloud providers are American. A US law from 2018 obliges such providers to disclose data in their possession, custody or control when legally required, "regardless of whether such communication, record, or other information is located within or outside of the United States". A European data centre doesn't change that. Your own equipment, with your own keys, does.
What the cloud does better
An honest comparison has to include the other side. Cloud services have real strengths:
- No equipment to look after. The provider takes care of the data centre, the servers and their physical security.
- Off-site from day one. Your copy is automatically in another building, often in another country – safe from a fire, flood or burglary at your office.
- Start small, pay for what you use. With a few hundred gigabytes, the bill is small and you start in minutes.
Microsoft also points out what often goes wrong with in-house systems: backups that "might be infrequent, untested, or stored on-site". A fair warning – your own system is only as good as its setup and care, so it needs a copy elsewhere, regular restore tests and someone responsible for it.
Your cloud office suite is not your backup
Many businesses assume that because their email and files are in Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, they are backed up. Microsoft, for one, sees it differently. Its guide to shared responsibility in the cloud says that "for all cloud deployment types, you own your data and identities", and lists customer data as the customer's responsibility even for ready-made online services such as Microsoft 365. Microsoft's Services Agreement for its consumer services is blunter: "We recommend that you regularly backup Your Content and Data that you store on the Services."
The built-in safety nets have limits. In SharePoint, for example, deleted items stay in the recycle bin for 93 days. Microsoft does offer backup for Microsoft 365 – but as a separate service, charged every month for each gigabyte protected. A well-built own system can keep copies of your cloud office data too, where the service allows it.
How you pay
| Own system | Cloud | |
|---|---|---|
| How you pay | Once for the equipment; setup and support as work | Every month, per terabyte or per user, for as long as you use it |
| When your data grows | Nothing changes until the disks are full | The bill grows with every terabyte |
| Price changes | None for equipment you already own | Decided by the provider – several popular services raised prices in 2026 |
| Full restore of 5 TB | Hours, over the office network | Days, on a 100 Mbit/s internet line |
| Without internet | Keeps working | Doesn't work |
| Equipment to look after | Yes – by you or your IT partner | No |
| Copy in another building | Needs a second box | Built in |
With little data, cloud storage can be the cheaper start – for a few hundred gigabytes it is honestly hard to beat. But the more data and history you keep, the bigger the monthly bill, every month, for as long as you use the service – while your own equipment is paid for once. What drives the cost of your own system is explained in what your own backup system costs.
Your own system must be protected too
Owning the system doesn't make it safe by itself. In a Sophos survey, 94% of organisations hit by ransomware said the attackers had tried to compromise their backups, and 57% of those attempts succeeded. Where backups were compromised, the median recovery cost was eight times higher than where they weren't. So a good system lets office computers add new copies but not delete or overwrite old ones, keeps a copy elsewhere and is checked regularly. More in ransomware in small and medium-sized businesses.
The best of both: your own system plus an encrypted copy elsewhere
For most businesses we recommend a combination:
- In the office: your own backup system, for fast everyday restores and full control.
- At a second location you control – a branch, a second office, the owner's home: a smaller box that automatically receives an encrypted copy. If the office burns down or is burgled, the data survives. If someone steals the second box, they get nothing readable.
- No second location? The encrypted copy can go to a cloud storage service. The provider then holds only scrambled data it can't read, and the keys stay with you.
That meets the 3-2-1 backup rule: three copies, two kinds of storage, one off-site. What "encrypted" means at each step: encryption at backup, at rest and in transit.
When the cloud is the better choice
- You have only a few hundred gigabytes and work mostly in online applications.
- There is no office, or no safe place for equipment – for example, a fully remote team.
- Nobody, inside the company or outside it, will take responsibility for looking after the system.
Then a reputable cloud service – ideally with encryption keys only you hold – is a sensible choice. Otherwise your own system deserves a serious look, especially if your data is sensitive, large or critical to daily work.
Do you want your data to be yours alone?
You do not have to choose between the convenience of the cloud and control. Call us and we will tell you what fits your company – your own system, the cloud or a mix of both – and why, without selling you anything you do not need.
With our Cybersecurity and data protection service you get your own cloud for the team and protected copies on your premises: your data never leaves the company, there are no monthly fees and the equipment is affordable.
Sources
- Backblaze Pricing and Product Updates (2026) – Backblaze blog
- Backblaze Product and Pricing Updates (2023) – Backblaze blog
- May 2026: Wasabi Pricing – Wasabi documentation
- 2026 Microsoft 365 packaging and pricing updates – Microsoft Licensing
- Pricing model for Microsoft 365 Backup – Microsoft Learn
- Shared responsibility in the cloud – Microsoft Learn
- Microsoft Services Agreement – Microsoft
- Restore items in the Recycle Bin of a SharePoint site – Microsoft Support
- 18 U.S. Code § 2713 – Required preservation and disclosure of communications and records – Cornell LII
- The impact of compromised backups on ransomware outcomes – Sophos