SEO Audit Results: Which Problems Should You Fix First?
An SEO audit report can list hundreds of "issues", but usually only a few of them matter. Fix them in this order: first anything that stops Google from crawling or indexing your important pages; then problems on the pages that bring customers – service pages, product categories, the contact page; then improvements that visitors will notice; and only at the end the cosmetic warnings that audit tools show by default. What matters is which pages they affect and whether those pages matter to your business.
Why audit reports look worse than they are
Audit tools compare every page with a long list of rules and mark many of them in red. That list mixes requirements Google actually documents with rules of thumb created by the tool's makers. One missing tag in a page template can appear as 400 "errors" because it repeats on 400 pages. And a tool cannot know which pages bring you enquiries and which one is an old news item nobody reads.
So before you open the list of issues, write down your 10–20 most important pages: the home page, the main service or product category pages, the pages with the most search traffic in Search Console and the pages where enquiries happen. Then judge every issue by one question: does it affect these pages, and how much?
Priority 1: problems that keep pages out of Google
These come first, because nothing else matters while they exist. Google's documentation lists the usual reasons a page is not crawled or indexed: problems with the server or network, robots.txt rules that block access, pages that require a login, robots meta rules that disallow indexing, and low-quality content.
- Important pages marked noindex. Often left over from the staging version of the site. A page with a noindex rule is not indexed.
- Important sections blocked in robots.txt. Check that a rule meant for system folders doesn't block pages that should be found.
- Server errors (5xx) and timeouts. When Google's crawlers get server errors they slow down, and URLs that keep returning a server error are eventually dropped from the index.
- Wrong canonical tags or redirects on key pages. A classic template bug is a canonical tag that points from every page to the home page.
- Manual actions and security issues. If Search Console's Manual actions report shows an action, some or all of the site may not be shown in Google results. Hacked content and malware warnings belong here too.
Check these in Google Search Console, not only in a third-party tool: the Page indexing report, the URL Inspection tool for individual pages, and the Manual actions and Security issues reports. If you don't have access to your own company's Search Console, sorting that out is step zero – see who controls your domain, hosting, code and accounts.
Read the Page indexing report correctly
Many audits treat every URL that is not indexed as a problem. Google doesn't. Its help page for the report says the goal is to get the canonical version of every important page indexed, and that you should not expect all URLs on your site to be indexed. Several statuses are perfectly normal:
| Status | What it usually means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Alternate page with proper canonical tag | A duplicate correctly points to the main version | Nothing, according to Google |
| Page with redirect | An old URL that now redirects | Normal after a redesign; check that the target is right |
| Not found (404) | The page no longer exists | Fine if it was removed on purpose; use a 301 redirect if it moved |
| Duplicate without user-selected canonical | Google chose another URL as the main version | Look closer only if an important page is affected |
| Crawled – currently not indexed | Google fetched the page but did not index it | Common; investigate if it is one of your key pages |
| URL marked noindex or Server error (5xx) on important pages | These pages cannot appear in results | Fix first |
Priority 2: problems on the pages that bring customers
Next question: do those pages deserve to rank and turn visitors into enquiries? This is where most of the real gains are – and where tools are weakest, because they cannot judge content.
- Does every important search have one clear page? If "kitchen renovation" is covered by a paragraph on the home page and a short blog post, neither is a strong answer.
- Titles. Google's SEO Starter Guide describes a good title as unique to the page, clear and concise, and accurately describing the page's contents. Identical titles on all service pages are worth fixing; a title a few characters "too long" by a tool's measure usually is not.
- Thin or generic service pages. A service page that says only what every competitor says gives neither Google nor visitors a reason to choose it. See what a service page needs to generate qualified leads.
- Internal links. Important pages should be reachable from the menu and linked from related pages with descriptive link text. Google notes that link text tells users and Google something about the page you link to.
- Broken internal links and redirect chains on the way to key pages – usually quick to fix and worth doing.
Priority 3: page experience and speed
Speed and usability on phones matter to visitors, and Core Web Vitals are used by Google's ranking systems. But Google is clear about their weight: Search always seeks to show the most relevant content, even if the page experience is sub-par, and trying to get a perfect score just for SEO reasons may not be the best use of your time. Fix the problems people actually feel – a slow product listing, a layout that jumps while loading, a form that is hard to fill in on a phone – rather than chasing 100 out of 100. See also what to investigate before changing your hosting.
Priority 4: warnings that can usually wait
Google's SEO Starter Guide has a section on things it believes you shouldn't focus on, and several common audit warnings fall into that category:
| Audit warning | What Google says |
|---|---|
| Missing meta keywords | Google Search doesn't use the keywords meta tag. |
| Several H1 headings, or headings out of order | Semantic heading order helps screen readers, but for Google Search it doesn't matter if headings are out of order. |
| Low word count | The length of the content alone doesn't matter for ranking purposes. |
| Duplicate content | It's inefficient, but not something that will cause a manual action. |
| Crawl budget warnings on a small site | Google's crawl budget guide is meant for very large sites – roughly 1 million+ pages, or 10,000+ pages that change daily. |
| Missing meta descriptions | Worth writing for important pages, but Google says the snippet in results only occasionally comes from the meta description. |
"Can wait" does not mean "never". Missing alt text, for example, is a real problem for people who use screen readers. But none of these should be scheduled before a noindex on your main service page.
A simple way to sort the list
For each issue, answer three questions:
- Impact: does it keep pages out of Google, does it affect how well pages rank and convert, or is it cosmetic?
- Reach: does it affect your key pages, a whole template, or a few unimportant URLs?
- Effort: is it a one-line change in a template, or a rewrite of 30 pages?
Start with high impact, wide reach and low effort. Group fixes by template – one change to the service page template fixes every service page at once. Keep a short log of changes and dates. Google's Starter Guide says some changes take effect in a few hours and others can take several months, and suggests waiting a few weeks before judging whether a change helped. Our article on how long SEO takes and how to measure progress explains which numbers to watch.
Questions to ask whoever made the audit
- Which of these issues affect our most important pages?
- Which come from Google's documentation and which are the tool's own rules?
- What will change for visitors, or in Search Console, once this is fixed?
Turning the list into work
Technical items – templates, redirects, canonical tags, speed – are development work, best done in one planned release. Content items – weak service pages, missing answers, overlapping articles – need someone who knows the business. We handle the first as part of website development and redesign and the second through content marketing. If your audit points to work in either area, get in touch.
Sources
- SEO Starter Guide: The Basics – Google Search Central
- Page indexing report – Search Console Help
- How HTTP status codes, and network and DNS errors affect Google Search – Google Search Central
- Understanding page experience in Google Search results – Google Search Central
- Optimize your crawl budget – Google Search Central
- Manual Actions report – Search Console Help